By Bixyl Shuftan
It was
a little more than a year ago that Linden Lab officially opened Sansar,
it's "next-generation virtual world which had been in development for
over three years, experienced a number of delays, and was the subject of
no shortage of speculation by Second Life's residents.
My initial impression was that while interesting it's best feature was it's, potential for improvement.
Others had a firm thumbs down to the point
it couldn't be mentioned in the Second Life Friends Facebook group.
Since then, there have been some improvements to Sansar. Last month,
the Lab allowed content creators to sell custom avatars on Sansar's Marketplace. And less than two days later some appeared. As of the
writing of this article,
there were a total of 43 avatars either available for free or up for sale (some better than others). Among
those you can get for free now is the "
Draxacoon." The Lab also
expanded the number of areas, or "experiences" that residents could have from three to twenty.
There
are some visually stunning locations in Sansar. One of the more recent
ones is the "Roddenberry Nexus," which
according to Inara Pey was launched in August 1. Done by Linden Lab in cooperation with Roddenberry Entertainment, which is run by Eugene Roddenberry,
the son of the man who created "Star Trek." Giving it a look, I found
it offers more interactivity than previous Sansarbuilds I've seen with a lift that can move you between levels and buttons that when pressed will play recordings, such as one describing
the transporter visual effects or the Star Trek Animated Series.
There
was also
another cooperative build done by the Lab with the help of the Smithsonian American Art Museum. Among the most interesting stories I've seen was
a video by Draxtor Despress, showing a number of people holding a "Hoverderby" game. These people weren't just looking at Sansar, but interacting.
But there's still plenty to complain about Sansar. Sansar
is also a more restrictive place than Second Life. It was widely
expected from the begining there would be more restrictions on
adult content than Second Life. While I read somewhere at least one
builder tinkered with such builds, the most recent set of
content guidelines have pretty much stated "no nudity and sex."
Content
featuring sexually explicit content and activities, such as
pornography, sexual acts, nudity and sexual services, including solicitation and offers for such content, are prohibited.
The Lab does say, "However, in limited educational or scientific contexts, we may make exceptions to these policies in our sole discretion."
One example might be the piece of nude artwork Ryan Schultz saw at the
Smithsonian art exhibition. But
this wasn't the only problem Schultz saw. Even
mentioning the names "Sansar," Linden Lab," or "Second Life," on a build could get you in trouble.
Any
content or Sansar store listings that contain any references to Linden
Lab, Sansar, Second Life, or any other Linden Lab-related terminology that may imply a relationship with, sponsorship, endorsement, or employment by Linden Lab is prohibited.
So
even making a "Sansar" t-shirt would get you a takedown notice from the
Lab. And it's not just inworld content as in January,
Schultz was asked to remove some pictures, and there appeared to be a problem with the name he was using for his blog at the time, "Sansar Newsblog." Hassling a major source of news about a virtual world you want to get word out about, especially a friendly voice, (and a big source of information for this article) isn't exactly the best of business tactics. And then there's the following line.
Do not upload Content that promotes or could be construed as primarily intended to evade limitations on Prohibited Content.
This line of the Terms of Service certainly leaves a lot to interpretation. Considering the Lab's past behavior, some content creators might decide not to take chances with a certain idea and instead make and sell it on another virtual world. In addition to the lack of a fashion market, this is
probably one reason why Sansar has attracted little attention from more than a few bloggers. Though Schultz would say
this was a common case of most newer virtual worlds.
For
those frustrated by the long time it can take details to rezz in Second
Life sims,
Sansar can be just as bad or even worse. And there are apparently
some problems with buying Sansar dollars in bulk using the "bundle" option.
And
of course, while Sansar looks good, it still lacks the interactivity of
Second Life and OpsnSim worlds. As it's been stated before, it's
like comparing a theme park to a residential area, a nice place to
visit, but not one you can virtually live. The examples I've stated are Sansar at it's best. The majority of other "experiences" aren't as good.
For
these reasons, the userbase of Sansar remains tiny compared to Second
Life. In April, the Newser reported the next-generation virtual
world was
averaging less than fifty users a day. Schultz went further,
saying that the average was never higher than twenty. In fact,
the graph he gave showed it was sometimes less than ten per day. For now, it seems stuck at a tiny userbase.
So why has Linden Lab persisted in sticking with Sansar? The question has been raised on
whether the Lab has a "cultural shift" away from it's established virtual world to this unpopular newcomer,
numbers remained small. Yes, it's normal for a company to want to
show off it's latest product. But why leave out it's tried and true
moneymaker? Perhaps with the stories about cyber-affairs, incidents
like the "flying penis attack" on live TV, being banned from the
"Twitch" streaming service due to some of it's sims allowing explicit content, maybe the Lab is feeling it can't really mention Second Life much to a mainstream audience. Another possible reason,
with the talk about "safe spaces" at colleges where controversial
speech is prohibited, perhaps the Lab is wondering if the next generation is looking less for the ability to express oneself and more about security from what might offend them.
As
for the possibility of Linden Lab closing down Second Life anything
soon to force it's population to Sansar: not a chance. Near the start of
it's development before it even had a name, Will Burns once commented
if Linden Lab made such a move, about a third would move onto the new
grid, a third to smaller virtual worlds, and a third would give up on
virtual worlds altogether. Today, I'd have to say if Linden Lab made
such a suicidal move, in my opinion less than five percent would be
inclined to move on to Sansar as their primary virtual world. While
Linden Lab might survive thanks to it's Blocksworld income, it would be a
much smaller company. Of the rest of Second Life's residents, it's my guess about three-fifths would move on to the various smaller
virtual worlds, perhaps some moving between two or three to continue to
meet up with friends. And the rest would likely give up on anything more
than a passing interest in virtual worlds. Even for those who moved,
they would most likely not spend as much money. It's one thing to invest
money in virtual land and property if you believe the grid will be
around for years. But if you're not sure how things will be six months
down the road, you may not be so eager to put down that money.
In any event, Sansar is very much a work in progress compared to Second Life, and even the more established Opensim worlds. It still needs at least a year, probably longer, before it can truly stand on it's own. For those who insist Linden Lab should get rid of it, such as one person I talked to who called it "the Edsel of virtual worlds," keep in mind the Edsel was in production for three years before it's makers finally gave up on it. Most likely, it will take longer than that before the Lab decides it's efforts are best spent elsewhere.
Sources: Ryan Schultz (formerly the Sansar Newsblog), Modem World, Sansar , Draxtor Despres, venturebeat.com
Bixyl Shuftan
For Firran (the feline race) and Harani players who misbehave, they're sent to the Solis prison, "times can vary from as little as two minutes to as long as several days." They also get a "debuff" that removes their ability to fight or get on a mount. There are a few things to do there, such as break crates to get the black and white striped jail clothes, do prison quests to reduce their time, or escape.
